Newsletter
  • Guides
  • Previews
    • Indie Games
    • PS4
    • PC
    • Xbox One
    • Nintendo Switch
    • Nintendo 3DS
    • PS Vita
    • PS3
    • Xbox 360
    • Wii U
  • Site Info
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Staff Directory
    • Join Our Team
    • Privacy Policy
      • Cookies Policy
    • RSS Feeds
    • Social Media
      • Youtube
      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • Twitch
      • Instagram
      • Tumblr
      • Linkedin
      • Pinterest
      • Discord
  • Discord
  • Store
  • Logitech G
  • green man gaming
  • Affiliates
    • GAMIVO.com
    • Logitech
    • Astro Gaming
    • Nord VPN
    • Best Buy
    • Namecheap Hosting
    • Blue Mic
    • Ultimate Ears
    • Jaybird
Tuesday, June 6, 2023
BG
  • News
    • All
    • Esports
    • Interviews
    esports tournament dates 2023

    Don’t Miss These Major Esports Tournaments Coming in 2023!

    explore a new world of esports - bet successfully on valorant matches!

    Explore a New Era of eSports: Bet Successfully on Valorant Matches

    betting on video games - 5 tops picks

    Betting on Video Games: 5 top picks

    Kristala Gets Exclusive Beta Demo

    esports betting featured image

    5 Secrets of Bankroll Management That You Don’t Know

    Wanted: Dead Enemies and Bosses Explained Video

    8 Minutes of New Atomic Heart Gameplay

    Chance to make money with valorant?

    Valorant, CS: GO, Dota 2 – Just Online Games or an Opportunity to Make Money on Bets?

    Amazon Luna Games Coming in February

    Trending Tags

    • Top Stories
    • PlayStation
    • Xbox
    • Nintendo
    • Retro Games
    • Mobile Games
    • Indie Games
    • Square Enix
    • Sony
    • Microsoft
    • PAX
    • EGX
    • Gamescom
    • Rockstar Games
    • Electronic Arts
    • Activision Blizzard
    • E3 Expo
  • Reviews
    • All
    • Flash Game Reviews
    • Google Stadia
    • Indie Game Reviews
    • Mobile Game Reviews
    • Nintendo 3DS Reviews
    • Nintendo Switch Reviews
    • PC Reviews
    • PS Vita Reviews
    • PS3 Reviews
    • PS4 Reviews
    • PS5 Reviews
    • Retro Game Reviews
    • Reviews RoundUP
    • Xbox 360 Reviews
    • Xbox One Reviews

    Coffee Talk Episode 2: Hibiscus & Butterfly Nintendo Switch Review

    Atelier Ryza 3

    Atelier Ryza 3: Alchemist of the End & the Secret Key Nintendo Switch Review

    No More Heroes 3 PS4 Review

    Neptunia: Sisters vs Sisters PS4 Review

    Wanted: Dead Review

    The Legend of Heroes Trails From Zero

    The Legend of Heroes: Trails From Zero PC Review

    Amnesia: Memories + Later x Crowd Review

    Dusk Diver 2 PS5 Review

    Yurukill: The Culmination Games

    Yurukill: The Calumniation Games Nintendo Switch Review

    Trending Tags

    • Resident Evil
    • Call of Duty
    • Final Fantasy
    • Destiny
    • Borderlands
    • Halo
    • The Elder Scrolls
    • Fortnite
    • PUBG
    • Bioshock
    • The Witcher
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Second Opinion
    7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space

    7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space (Without Irritating Each Other!)

    explore a new world of esports - bet successfully on valorant matches!

    Explore a New Era of eSports: Bet Successfully on Valorant Matches

    betting on video games - 5 tops picks

    Betting on Video Games: 5 top picks

    esports betting featured image

    5 Secrets of Bankroll Management That You Don’t Know

    Popular games featured image

    The increasing popularity of online casinos

    Manga Review: Summertime Rendering Volumes 2 & 3

    buying, szelling, and trading csgo skins

    What To Expect When Buying, Selling, & Trading CS: GO Skins

    What Are the Best Ways to Gear Up in Retail WOW?

    Chance to make money with valorant?

    Valorant, CS: GO, Dota 2 – Just Online Games or an Opportunity to Make Money on Bets?

    Trending Tags

    • Is It A Classic?
    • Remember When
    • Do We Even Care Anymore?
    • Humpday Haikus
    • Top Series
    • Thirsty Thursday
    • Aging Gamer
    • On The Way To E3
  • Podcasts
    • All
    • The BagoCast
    • TSR BagoCast

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – The Future of Game Journalism

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Social Media & Esports

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Politics in Video Games Games

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Content Creators vs Game Journalist 2

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Titan Fall and Apex: Legends Hacked

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Content Creators vs Game Journalist

    BagoCast EP: 12 – Code Vein and the DLC

    Debate/Discussion: Bad Video Games That We Love

    Discussion/Debate: Is Bioware Gone?

    Trending Tags

    • Film Fallout
    • 8Bit Proof
    • Gaming Historia
    • Bago Anime Cast
    • Gamers In Beta
    • Gamers Unscripted
  • Videos

    So, You Wanna Play Junker Queen?

    Matchpoint Tennis Championships Live Review

    Void Slayer – Review

    The IDEAL Spider-Man VR Game

    Crunchyroll Panel Full Video @ Anime Frontier

    BPM: Bullets Per Minute – Shooting to The Beat (Review)

    She Will Punish Them – Warning: Mature Content (Early Access Review)

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – The Future of Game Journalism

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Social Media & Esports

  • Geek Culture
    • All
    • Anime and Manga
    • Anime/Manga Review
    • Collectibles
    • Comic Books
    • Cosplay
    • Movies
    • Tech
    • TV Shows

    RiotPWR Gaming Controller RP1950 Is Future Proof

    Manga Review: Summertime Rendering Volumes 2 & 3

    Pwnage Releases New Info On Stormbreaker, The Magnesium Alloy Gaming Mouse

    Eminence in Shadow Mobile RPG Gets New Trailer, Available Now

    Crunchyroll Announces Anime Frontier Panels and Premieres

    Crunchyroll Announces Hell’s Paradise, The Ancient Magus’ Bride S2, and More Upcoming Anime

    The Quintessential Quintuplets Movie Gets New Key Visual, Tickets Now on Sale

    Crunchyroll Rich Presence Now Available on Discord

    Udon Entertainment Announces Persona 4 Arena & Ultimax Manga Coming 2023

    Trending Tags

    • Movie Reviews
    • Movie News
    • TV News
    • TV Episode Review
    • Episode Guide
    • Competitive Gaming
    • Tech News
    • Tech Review
    • Anime and Manga News
    • Anime and Manga Review
    • Comic Book News
    • Comic Book Review
  • Forum
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Esports
    • Interviews
    esports tournament dates 2023

    Don’t Miss These Major Esports Tournaments Coming in 2023!

    explore a new world of esports - bet successfully on valorant matches!

    Explore a New Era of eSports: Bet Successfully on Valorant Matches

    betting on video games - 5 tops picks

    Betting on Video Games: 5 top picks

    Kristala Gets Exclusive Beta Demo

    esports betting featured image

    5 Secrets of Bankroll Management That You Don’t Know

    Wanted: Dead Enemies and Bosses Explained Video

    8 Minutes of New Atomic Heart Gameplay

    Chance to make money with valorant?

    Valorant, CS: GO, Dota 2 – Just Online Games or an Opportunity to Make Money on Bets?

    Amazon Luna Games Coming in February

    Trending Tags

    • Top Stories
    • PlayStation
    • Xbox
    • Nintendo
    • Retro Games
    • Mobile Games
    • Indie Games
    • Square Enix
    • Sony
    • Microsoft
    • PAX
    • EGX
    • Gamescom
    • Rockstar Games
    • Electronic Arts
    • Activision Blizzard
    • E3 Expo
  • Reviews
    • All
    • Flash Game Reviews
    • Google Stadia
    • Indie Game Reviews
    • Mobile Game Reviews
    • Nintendo 3DS Reviews
    • Nintendo Switch Reviews
    • PC Reviews
    • PS Vita Reviews
    • PS3 Reviews
    • PS4 Reviews
    • PS5 Reviews
    • Retro Game Reviews
    • Reviews RoundUP
    • Xbox 360 Reviews
    • Xbox One Reviews

    Coffee Talk Episode 2: Hibiscus & Butterfly Nintendo Switch Review

    Atelier Ryza 3

    Atelier Ryza 3: Alchemist of the End & the Secret Key Nintendo Switch Review

    No More Heroes 3 PS4 Review

    Neptunia: Sisters vs Sisters PS4 Review

    Wanted: Dead Review

    The Legend of Heroes Trails From Zero

    The Legend of Heroes: Trails From Zero PC Review

    Amnesia: Memories + Later x Crowd Review

    Dusk Diver 2 PS5 Review

    Yurukill: The Culmination Games

    Yurukill: The Calumniation Games Nintendo Switch Review

    Trending Tags

    • Resident Evil
    • Call of Duty
    • Final Fantasy
    • Destiny
    • Borderlands
    • Halo
    • The Elder Scrolls
    • Fortnite
    • PUBG
    • Bioshock
    • The Witcher
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Second Opinion
    7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space

    7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space (Without Irritating Each Other!)

    explore a new world of esports - bet successfully on valorant matches!

    Explore a New Era of eSports: Bet Successfully on Valorant Matches

    betting on video games - 5 tops picks

    Betting on Video Games: 5 top picks

    esports betting featured image

    5 Secrets of Bankroll Management That You Don’t Know

    Popular games featured image

    The increasing popularity of online casinos

    Manga Review: Summertime Rendering Volumes 2 & 3

    buying, szelling, and trading csgo skins

    What To Expect When Buying, Selling, & Trading CS: GO Skins

    What Are the Best Ways to Gear Up in Retail WOW?

    Chance to make money with valorant?

    Valorant, CS: GO, Dota 2 – Just Online Games or an Opportunity to Make Money on Bets?

    Trending Tags

    • Is It A Classic?
    • Remember When
    • Do We Even Care Anymore?
    • Humpday Haikus
    • Top Series
    • Thirsty Thursday
    • Aging Gamer
    • On The Way To E3
  • Podcasts
    • All
    • The BagoCast
    • TSR BagoCast

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – The Future of Game Journalism

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Social Media & Esports

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Politics in Video Games Games

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Content Creators vs Game Journalist 2

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Titan Fall and Apex: Legends Hacked

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Content Creators vs Game Journalist

    BagoCast EP: 12 – Code Vein and the DLC

    Debate/Discussion: Bad Video Games That We Love

    Discussion/Debate: Is Bioware Gone?

    Trending Tags

    • Film Fallout
    • 8Bit Proof
    • Gaming Historia
    • Bago Anime Cast
    • Gamers In Beta
    • Gamers Unscripted
  • Videos

    So, You Wanna Play Junker Queen?

    Matchpoint Tennis Championships Live Review

    Void Slayer – Review

    The IDEAL Spider-Man VR Game

    Crunchyroll Panel Full Video @ Anime Frontier

    BPM: Bullets Per Minute – Shooting to The Beat (Review)

    She Will Punish Them – Warning: Mature Content (Early Access Review)

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – The Future of Game Journalism

    Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – Social Media & Esports

  • Geek Culture
    • All
    • Anime and Manga
    • Anime/Manga Review
    • Collectibles
    • Comic Books
    • Cosplay
    • Movies
    • Tech
    • TV Shows

    RiotPWR Gaming Controller RP1950 Is Future Proof

    Manga Review: Summertime Rendering Volumes 2 & 3

    Pwnage Releases New Info On Stormbreaker, The Magnesium Alloy Gaming Mouse

    Eminence in Shadow Mobile RPG Gets New Trailer, Available Now

    Crunchyroll Announces Anime Frontier Panels and Premieres

    Crunchyroll Announces Hell’s Paradise, The Ancient Magus’ Bride S2, and More Upcoming Anime

    The Quintessential Quintuplets Movie Gets New Key Visual, Tickets Now on Sale

    Crunchyroll Rich Presence Now Available on Discord

    Udon Entertainment Announces Persona 4 Arena & Ultimax Manga Coming 2023

    Trending Tags

    • Movie Reviews
    • Movie News
    • TV News
    • TV Episode Review
    • Episode Guide
    • Competitive Gaming
    • Tech News
    • Tech Review
    • Anime and Manga News
    • Anime and Manga Review
    • Comic Book News
    • Comic Book Review
  • Forum
No Result
View All Result
BagoGames
No Result
View All Result

BagoGames > Articles > Opinion > Puzzle Game Design Philosophies

Puzzle Game Design Philosophies

Christopher Cross by Christopher Cross
7 years ago
in Opinion
Reading Time: 5 mins read
2
The Witness

(The Witness, Thekla Inc.)

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

RelatedStories

7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space

7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space (Without Irritating Each Other!)

3 weeks ago
explore a new world of esports - bet successfully on valorant matches!

Explore a New Era of eSports: Bet Successfully on Valorant Matches

3 weeks ago

This year has already seen one of the most highly-anticipated puzzle games come out to massive acclaim with The Witness. Jonathan Blow’s isolated island of conundrums is a game that is structured very differently from a lot of puzzle games that come out. Most notably is its implementation of an open-world structure that makes it have to re-think a lot of typical puzzle game standards.

I’ve also been playing a game called Monumental, by a smaller developer, Whipstitch Games. While The Witness sticks with a central mechanic for its puzzles, Monumental isn’t afraid to throw a bunch of different types of puzzles at the player. The design philosophies behind these games are so different yet cross paths on multiple occasions, which makes them worth comparing and analyzing on a deeper level.

Let’s begin with me saying that I have not finished either game; I am pretty far into The Witness, but not particularly far into Monumental. This being said, I feel like I have seen enough in both games to understand what I do and do not like. More importantly, the games are clever enough to set up a lot of the atmosphere and how the game will unfold in their first moments.

Let’s take the more traditional approach, which Monumental is not shy in leaning heavily into. The game opens with you reading a written log welcoming you to a research station on a seemingly deserted planet. There is no one on the station, but they were there at some point. I know this because the game has filled the entire station with diary entries from the main crew members.

Monumental
(Monumental, Whipstitch Games)

These diary entries also serve as a way of solving puzzles. Often clues are within these logs, making both the story and puzzle solutions dependent on you scavenging the entire station. The only things that can really be touched in Monumental are key pads and these written logs. The environment becomes stale and left behind by the game, despite it being something that holds so many solutions.

I found myself feeling like the ship itself was a puzzle in how it was designed because almost nothing in its architecture made sense. In order to unlock the research lab, you have to go to the commons area, then downstairs and input all five crew members’ codes — just to unlock the control room which has a large panel that unlocks the research lab.

Environment matters in an open-world puzzle game; otherwise, why is it open-world? The Witness has the solutions to puzzles embedded in its environments, but in ways that make tons of sense. It even has audio logs, something which Monumental‘s diary entries become comparable to, but those never feel as organic as The Witness‘.

Hidden around the environment in places that are usually inhabited by an anomaly in the world — somewhere that makes you go “Hmmm…I wonder why this is here” — these audio logs flesh out a story in a way that befits the atmosphere of The Witness. I’m not going to spoil either of the games’ stories, but The Witness has reveals in it that make you think about your place in the world and why you might be on an island solving puzzles.

The other thing is that The Witness is truly open-world because it never forces you to go down one path in order to unlock another. Stuck on a puzzle? Just move onto another one and come back to it later. You’re constantly learning from the environment, so it is often better to explore than to keep melting your brain on a single set of puzzles. Often I came back to the game after a little bit of a break and figured out the puzzle like that. There is an idea that the puzzle is not hard, it just requires you to think about it in different ways. And other puzzles can help prepare you to do just that.

The Witness
(The Witness, Thekla Inc.)

In Monumental, it doesn’t matter what puzzle you did before because it doesn’t have any bearing on the next puzzle. They are isolated and when they are trying to be their most clever, they feel more jarring and ridiculous. The first major puzzle I solved was one involving colours and trying to blend some colours with others to match a fixture on the wall that is a set of colours. There are multiple reasons why this is a terrible yet clever puzzle.

First of all, it is the solution to a puzzle which unlocks a crew member’s door. This is an issue because the solution to the puzzle can be found by any crew member, and yet it is specifically relegated to one member’s door. The other reason this is a terrible puzzle is because there isn’t any preparation for it, nor any follow-up to it. Everyone locks their doors with a different code, which can range from a mnemonic code to matching a melody found in a person’s room.

Tools are given to the player like a sound recorder that is used to record the melody, or a camera so players can take pictures of solutions/clues for puzzles, but they ultimately feel like random provisions. Why do I have a sound recorder? Why do I have a camera? No explanation is really given to explain these tools and their purpose, they just exist because the puzzle requires them to exist. But why does the puzzle exist in the way it does? To provide something clever and nothing more.

When I solved the colour puzzle, I felt like a genius. I also felt like I had wasted my time because it didn’t prepare me for anything. Even more basic puzzle games know that things need to amount to others. Picross follows one type of puzzle and just makes it harder. Sudoku is in a similar boat. Braid, as well. The Witness gives you symbols you don’t understand yet, but because it’s an open-world game you know to explore, and maybe you’ll find a solution.

The other factor important to note is that there is no indicator in Monumental about where to go next or what to look for to help solve the puzzle. It is so dependent on written diaries that when it doesn’t tell you what to do next, it’s confusing. The game knows it’s obtuse because it even has a built-in hint system that tells you exactly what you need to do next (for example: there is a melody in a room to record, go do so).

This should have been an indicator that the environment and puzzles are not well-defined because there is still a fail-safe if you can’t figure it out. The language of the puzzles are simply too varied to have a cohesive connection.

I don’t mean to beat Monumental into the ground, especially against something like The Witness, which may very well become a classic puzzle game in the vein of Myst. However, Monumental showcases a lot of the problems in puzzle design philosophies that should be accounted for, especially when trying to make a player want to continue through your world.

Jonathan Blow understood with The Witness that story isn’t important in a puzzle game. In fact, it should probably always be secondary. The point of a puzzle game is to have puzzles, and the reward in The Witness is a story as well as a sense of accomplishment. An overall understanding of The Witness‘ world is more rewarding than figuring out what obtuse puzzle was randomly placed in Monumental.


A copy of Monumental was provided by Whipstich Games and used for the purpose of this article

Tags: Puzzle GamesThe WitnessTop Stories
ShareTweetShare


Previous Post

Dark Souls III Pre-Orders Live for PS4, Xbox One, and PC

Next Post

Carmageddon: Max Damage Coming to Consoles This Year

Subscribe
Connect with
Login
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Notify of
guest
The comment form collects your name, email and content to allow us to keep track of the comments placed on the website. Please read and accept our website Terms and Privacy Policy to post a comment.
Save my name, email, and website in this browser cookies for the next time I comment.

I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
guest
The comment form collects your name, email and content to allow us to keep track of the comments placed on the website. Please read and accept our website Terms and Privacy Policy to post a comment.
Save my name, email, and website in this browser cookies for the next time I comment.

2 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
trackback
The Guest Review
7 years ago

[…] recently talked about puzzle design philosophies, and one of my complaints was the use of obtuse puzzles that make no sense in the context of the […]

0
0
Reply
trackback
Games Fleadh Calls for Tax Relief for Irish Game Developers
7 years ago

[…] Puzzle Game Design Philosophies […]

0
0
Reply
wpdiscuz   wpDiscuz

BAGOGAMES WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Get this week's top news, reviews, guides, videos and opinion for your favorite games, movies, TV and tech in your email every Friday.

Don't worry, we don't spam.

NEW ON BAGOGAMES

esports tournament dates 2023
Esports

Don’t Miss These Major Esports Tournaments Coming in 2023!

by Trevor Kincaid
2 weeks ago
7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space
Opinion

7 Tips to Game in a Shared Space (Without Irritating Each Other!)

by Trevor Kincaid
3 weeks ago
explore a new world of esports - bet successfully on valorant matches!
Esports

Explore a New Era of eSports: Bet Successfully on Valorant Matches

by Trevor Kincaid
3 weeks ago

LATEST PODCASTS & VIDEOS

Currently Playing

Void Slayer – Review

Void Slayer – Review

Game Reviews

The IDEAL Spider-Man VR Game

Opinion

BPM: Bullets Per Minute – Shooting to The Beat (Review)

Game Reviews

She Will Punish Them – Warning: Mature Content (Early Access Review)

Game Reviews

Bagocast: Interview with Upper Echelon Gamers – The Future of Game Journalism

Opinion

FOLLOW US

BagoGames

BagoGames.com © 2023 BagoGames LLC. All rights reserved.

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Staff Directory
  • Join Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Newsletter
  • RSS Feeds
  • Discord Server
  • BG Store
  • OpenCritic
  • green man gaming
  • Logitech G
  • GAMIVO.com
  • ASTRO Gaming
  • Logitech
  • Namecheap Hosting
  • Nord VPN
  • Best Buy
  • Blue Mic
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Guides

Follow Us

  • Login
  • Sign Up
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Opinion
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Geek Culture
  • Previews
  • Guides
  • Short Videos
  • Forum
  • Site Info
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Join Our Team
    • Staff Directory
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newsletter
    • RSS Feeds

BagoGames.com © 2023 BagoGames LLC. All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz